8 Rated Books Book Reviews

Book Review: Eon Dragoneye Reborn by Alison Goodman

Title: Eon: Dragoneye Reborn

Author: Alison Goodman

Genre: Young Adult, Fantasy


Publisher: Viking Juvenile (Penguin)
Publication Date: December 2008
Hardcover: 544 pages

Stand alone or series: First book in a planned duology.

Why did I read this book: Eon: Dragoneye Reborn has garnered a lot of buzz both online and in bookstores. This marks one of Penguin’s biggest Young Adult books of 2009, and so when we were offered a review copy of this novel, I hastily accepted!

Summary: (from Penguin Group USA)
Action — a stunning magic system—swordplay galore!

Eon has been studying the ancient art of Dragon Magic for four years, hoping he’ll be able to apprentice to one of the twelve energy dragons of good fortune. But he also has a dark secret. He is actually Eona, a sixteen-year-old girl who has been living a dangerous lie for the chance to become a Dragoneye, the human link to an energy dragon’s power. It is forbidden for females to practice the Dragon Magic and, if discovered, Eon faces a terrible death. After a dazzling sword ceremony, Eon’s affinity with the twelve dragons catapults him into the treacherous world of the Imperial court where he makes a powerful enemy, Lord Ido. As tension builds and Eon’s desperate lie comes to light, readers won’t be able to stop turning the pages…


Eon is a twelve year old boy with a twisted leg from a traumatic accident from his early childhood. He also is a Dragoneye candidate, the first lame candidate ever to attempt the ceremony of mirrors, and to try to become a Dragoneye apprentice. Every new year, a different Dragoneye becomes the ascendant, and an apprentice is chosen by the Dragon. This time, it is the Rat Dragon, and Eon joins the boys to complete the grueling ceremony and stand hopeful in front of the mirrors. Only Eon hides a desperate secret–he actually is a sixteen year old girl, named Eona. Singled out by her master because of her raw power and talent to see all twelve dragons with her spirit sight, Eona has been trained and forced to masquerade as a boy. Saved from the deadly salt mines, Eona’s master is the only other person who knows her secret, and it is one they must guard with their lives. Should Eona’s true identity be discovered, she and her master will face certain death. When the ceremony commences, however, Eona becomes chosen not by the ascendant dragon, but by the Mirror Dragon–lost from the Dragon Council for five hundred years. Eona is soon plunged into a dangerous new world of political struggle and intrigue as opposing forces fight for control of the empire. All the hopes of those loyal to the Emperor relies on Eona and her dragon, and she must bear the burden of her secret and try to outwit the deep treachery that threatens her world.

Eon: Dragoneye Reborn marks a huge push for Penguin books, and boasts aspirations of becoming the next Eragon, or with the more widespread appeal of Harry Potter. And truly, Eon reaches new highs rarely seen in young adult fiction. At face level, Eona is your typical fantasy heroine–the girl masquerading as a boy shtick is an old standby in speculative fiction, especially when combined with the notion that on Eona’s shoulders the Fate of the World rests. But it is her struggle to embrace herself and the true nature of her bond with her dragon that Eon truly shines, going beyond the standard fantasy tropes. What I loved most about this novel was its beautifully complex evaluation of gender roles, and the self-perception of gender in its characters. “Eon” struggles with her true self, burying Eona and never allowing the female part of her surface. She even thinks of herself as male, takes draughts and drugs to enhance her “Sun” powers (the male strength, thus repressing her female “moon” elements) despising and refusing to acknowledge her true self. Eona’s struggle with gender and self-perception mimics the insecurity and trepidation adolescents feel trying to grope with their own identities, and as a result it makes Eona that much more translatable and real to readers of either gender, or of all ages for that matter.

It’s also very interesting to see that two other major characters in Eona’s life as a Dragoneye also explore gender dynamics. Lady Dela serves as Eona’s guide to the political games in the palace, and is a “contraire”–a woman’s spirit born into a man’s body. Lady Dela is a concubine, dresses as a woman, and for all intents and purposes is female in every way except in body. Her bodyguard Ryko also becomes one of Eona’s fast friends and companions, and he is a eunuch trying to hide his deep emotions and love for Lady Dela. It’s an intriguing dynamic, and an intensely layered and detailed dissection of gender roles for any novel, let alone a young adult book. All three characters hold lower stations in a society that isn’t made for them–Lady Dela is seen as a freak, Ryko without his sexual maleness, and Eona as a powerless girl masquerading as a boy. In a land where tradition is law, all three struggle to find their own sense of self.

In terms of world building, Eon also excels. Drawing on a blend of Asian cultures but leaning mostly on an interpretation of Chinese dynasties and beliefs, Eona’s universe is beautifully developed and fully realized. I loved the cycle of ascendant dragons and their Dragoneyes and the ceremony of a dragon choosing its apprentice. The details of magic and how it is used in this world is also fascinating and detailed–a Dragoneye wields his energy dragon’s power at a great cost, eventually bringing him (or her) death as the energy draws from the Dragoneye’s Hua or lifeforce. The numerous rituals, the depiction of the dragons and of power are pure brilliance–Ms. Goodman does a phenomenal job of creating and maintaining her world. Similarly, the court intrigues, the struggles between the Emperor and his usurper half-brother with the help of the power-crazed Rat Dragoneye Lord Ido are riveting storylines. The power plays and struggles are plotted convincingly and executed with admirable aplomb. This makes Eon an immensely readable and detailed novel, and although some of the political maneuvering may be lost on younger readers.

My only real complaint with Eon is one that I have with many novels, especially of the young adult or urban fantasy persuasion; how obvious and predictable certain plot elements are. From early on in the novel, it is transparently obvious what Eona must do to use her dragon’s power and save her friends and her Emperor–however, Eona (and everyone else) remains oblivious to this information until it is too late. This is an incredibly irritating writing technique, but despite this I still found Eon a highly enjoyable novel. Once Eona finally does figure out what she must do, it’s a gripping climax and leaves readers breathless, anxious for more. I for one cannot wait for the release of book two, Eona: The Last Dragoneye!

Notable Quotes/Parts: I loved the buildup to the Dragoneye ceremony, and the trials each candidate had to undergo–Eona’s ordeal in the arena, fighting her horrible armsmaster is a tense scene and one of my favorites in the novel. I also loved the depiction of the energy dragons, from the initial appearance of the Rat Dragon in the arena:

Light shivered in the air above the carved gold rat. Slowly, a large claw slid into the reflection, pale blue scales glowing above five opal talons. The Rat Dragon was descending from his perch, his translucent body only solid and visible in the mirror as he passed by it. A reflection without an original. It was the first time I’d ever seen one of the spirit beasts in full physical form. My own gasp was echoed around the arena. A powerfully muscled foreleg came into view, the scales darkening into ocean blue as the underside of a broad chest and shoulder followed in the glass. Next, a beard, the white hair thick and tapered like a horse’s tail. And for a fleeting moment, beneath the coarse strands, I saw the dragon’s pearl–his source of wisdom and power–tucked under his chin and shining with blue iridescence. Then it was hidden by his flared muzzle, the delicate scales and fine horse nostrils accentuating the size of the fang that curved from his upper lip.

THe dragon turned to stare across the sand at the emperor, one large dark eye visible in the mirror, his broad bow crowned by two curled horns. I heard nervous murmuring from the crowd as both of his forelegs reached the sand, his sinuous body stretched full length in the reflection. Then it coiled like a snake and dropped behind him, the invisible weight sending up a cloud of sand and dust that fell back over his body, giving us a shimmering outline of him. He shook his head, dislodging more sand, then turned and looked at himself in the glass, the endless depth of his eyes giving him an expression of sadness. Two pale blue membranes extended out from each shoulder and rippled in the sunlight like watered silk, then folded back against his body. The heavy head swung around to face us again, the mirror showing the solid line of his spine and the thick fall of his white mane. Although his eyes were no longer reflected, I knew he was studying us, choosing his apprentice.

A beautiful depiction without being overly-ornate. Ms. Goodman has a wonderful gift for storytelling.

Additional Thoughts: Fans of Eon should also consider checking out one of the authors who blurbed this novel, the wonderful Tamora Pierce.


When I was a young adult myself, the Song of the Lioness quartet was one of my absolute favorite series’ of books. Starting with Alanna: The First Adventure, the quartet follows young Alanna Trebond as she masquerades as “Alan” to become the first female knight in Tortall.


Another recommended series is Lian Hearn’s Tales of the Otori books, which draw from feudal Japan as a setting, combined with magic, heartbreak and intrigue. A while ago Christine of The Happily Ever After reviewed the first book Across the Nightingale Floor.

Verdict: Excellent world-building, outstanding, layered characters, and an awesome attention to detail make Eon a fantastic read, and one of my favorite books of 2009 so far. Highly recommended.

Rating: 8 Excellent – and I cannot wait for the concluding volume of this duology!

Reading Next: White Witch Black Curse by Kim Harrison


  • Kris
    February 13, 2009 at 12:26 am

    😯 This looks terrific. I was going to ask whether it was like the Tamora Pierce series and then you answered for me. lol. I’ll definitely be on the look out for this one.

    Great review, Thea.

  • KMont
    February 13, 2009 at 5:15 am

    You know, at first the book’s official blurb confused me; it reveals what gender th protagonist really is yet goes on to refer to her as a ‘he’. I thought that was really confusing, especially since it’s a blurb trying to sell the book. Or maybe I am just having a really slooooow morning.

    Your personal explanations about gender roles in this explained it though and helped a lot. I admit at first that particular aspect seemed pretty overwhelming as I read your review. I’ve not had ANY experience with adolescents old enough to struggle with a gender identity, but the more I thought about it, why not, I suppose. It does happen.

    This really does sound like a very complex book, very detailed as you say, so I’m feeling your disappointment that certain aspects were too shallow and easy to predict. This is something I’ve kind of struggled with on more than one young adult novel and have wondered if I just expect too much from them, maybe want them to be every bit as complex as an adult book. It’s interesting though that you say young readers might not understand the political aspects of the book, yet other important factors are easily given away. What’s the right balance? Does anyone know?

    Am I making sense? LOL, it’s been a weird morning.

    Still, this sounds like a really good book. I think I will pick it up! Lovely review, Thea!

  • KMont
    February 13, 2009 at 5:17 am

    Oh and I’m ignoring for the moment the reminder that you’ve got White Witch, Black Curse in your possession. I mean, I’m happy for you, *sniffle*, really! But, yeah…. *pout*

  • katiebabs
    February 13, 2009 at 5:38 am

    This book was being promoted heavily at Comic Con with posters and bookmarks, but no free copies to reviewers 🙁
    Have you read City of Bones? I got that one, which they compare to Melissa Marr’s series, which I think you will love.

  • AnimeJune
    February 13, 2009 at 6:02 am

    Oh, I love this review. Love love love. I reviewed this book for The Green Man Review (.com) and thought the same thing – great world building and interesting characters (but, just like your review – a really, REALLY obvious solution that took 200 pages for the heroine to figure out).

    I’m also a fan of Tamora Pierce – I loved her books as a kid. I liked, however, that Eon presented the psychological struggle of pretending to be someone else that Alanna from Pierce’s books didn’t. Alanna always thought of herself as herself, whether she was believed to be a boy or a girl – but Eon actually hates her female half and that was some pretty interesting conflict.

  • Thea
    February 13, 2009 at 8:51 am

    Kris–Thanks! And yes, it’s very much like the Alanna books, only far more detailed and with a greater focus on the identity implications of pretending to be someone you aren’t. It’s a fascinating read and I definitely recommend it! Especially for Tamora Pierce fans 😉

    Kmont–The gender dynamics are really well done; even after we know that Eon is actually Eona, she still tries to bury her female side and sees herself as male. Everyone else refers to her as a male as well (“Lord Eon”), so there is this sort of confusion–you’re not alone! But it just works. I’m very impressed with Alison Goodman’s writing, I’ll have to pick up some of her older books!

    And I think that Eona’s struggle to become someone she cannot ever be is a metaphor for adolescents struggling to find who they are in real life–not necessarily a gender identity search, but just an identity issue period. There are friends, pressures, trying to “fit in”, and whatever other myriad problems everyone faces as a teen, and Eona’s struggles kind of mimic this search for oneself. I guess that’s what I was trying to say, if that makes any sense? LOL. It’s 8:44 am. 😆

    And even though I really hate this sort of ‘tension by delayed information’ writing technique, Eon is still a fantastic book. (The other example I can think of off the top of my head that uses this irritating technique are the Succubus books by Richelle Mead. I love these books, but they are so predictable. It’s ok though, because the characters are so well written that you’re willing to forgive the obvious plotlines!)

    Psst…you may have a copy of White Witch Black Curse soon too. We might be giving away an early copy. Maybe on Monday. Details will follow this weekend!!! *ninja vanish*

    Katie–I have to pick up City of Ashes. I’ve heard wonderful things about the series, but haven’t had a chance to read it yet. Hmm, know where I can score a free copy? Heh. I definitely recommend you give Eon a read! And on a shallow note, isn’t the cover gorgeous?!

    AnimeJune–Thank you!!! I’ll make sure to check out your review.

    [i]I’m also a fan of Tamora Pierce – I loved her books as a kid. I liked, however, that Eon presented the psychological struggle of pretending to be someone else that Alanna from Pierce’s books didn’t. Alanna always thought of herself as herself, whether she was believed to be a boy or a girl – but Eon actually hates her female half and that was some pretty interesting conflict.[/i]

    Exactly!!! You nailed it. What I loved so so so much about this book was Eona’s struggles and her own inner dialogue, pushing down her female emotions and self. Alanna never really struggled with this psychological side (although there was all that Jonathan drama!). Now I’m itching to reread the Alanna books! :mrgreen:

  • Li
    February 13, 2009 at 1:06 pm

    Ooooh, I was thinking of the Alanna books when I read the first few paragraphs. And then Lynn Flewelling’s Tamir trilogy as well? The heroine of that had her twin brother killed at birth, and then disguised herself as a boy, IIRC.

    I’m tempted by this one – have to say you make it sound good 🙂

  • orannia
    February 14, 2009 at 5:19 pm

    Ohhh, great review Thea – thank you! I have this on my TBR list and I’m really looking forward to it.

    And I remember the Alanna series 🙂 I still read some of Tamora Pierce’s books from time to time (mostly the Protector of the Small series, which I love). And I’m waiting for Bloodhound to be published (it’s the sequel to Terrier).

    City of Ashes sounds interesting *scampers off to Google it*

  • Anonymous
    June 11, 2009 at 11:27 am

    🙄 👿

  • Jena
    November 17, 2009 at 12:42 am

    I’m just writing my review for Eon. Do you have any idea when the sequel will be released? I’m eager to read the rest of the story!

  • Thea
    November 17, 2009 at 12:58 am

    Jena – As of the author’s website right now, book 2 (Eona) is scheduled for sometime in 2010! The sooner the better, I hope :mrgreen:

  • none
    September 2, 2010 at 11:00 am

    What is wrong with you. that book was horrible. how could you compare it to harry potter. you have just lowered the reliability of the sight 👿

  • The Leaning Pile of Books | Fantasy Cafe | Reviews of Fantasy and Science Fiction Books
    March 6, 2011 at 7:08 am

    […] would be the book I purchased because the sequel showed up this week. Thea from The Book Smugglers (her review) had recommended me this book at one point, so it’s been on my wish list for a little […]

  • Eon: Dragoneye Reborn by Alison Goodman | The Lost Entwife
    March 28, 2011 at 3:11 am

    […] The Book Smugglers […]

  • Joint Review: Singing the Dogstar Blues by Alison Goodman | The Book Smugglers
    June 22, 2012 at 2:27 am

    […] did we read this book: Thea is a huge fan of Alison Goodman’s recent fantasy novels Eon and Eona, and when we both happened across this repackaged first novel while on a break from BEA […]

  • Nate is Great
    December 28, 2013 at 2:02 pm

    It was a great book.

  • Eon: The Dragoneye Reborn by Alison Goodman | One Book Two
    March 24, 2016 at 3:07 pm

    […] The Book Smugglers […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.