8 Rated Books Book Reviews

Book Review: The Girl of Fire and Thorns by Rae Carson

Title: The Girl of Fire and Thorns

Author: Rae Carson

Genre: Fantasy, Young Adult

Publisher: Greenwillow Books (US) / Gollancz (UK)
Publication Date: September 2011 (US & UK)
Hardcover: 432 pages

Once a century, one person is chosen for greatness.

Elisa is the chosen one.

But she is also the younger of two princesses, the one who has never done anything remarkable. She can’t see how she ever will.

Now, on her sixteenth birthday, she has become the secret wife of a handsome and worldly king—a king whose country is in turmoil. A king who needs the chosen one, not a failure of a princess.

And he’s not the only one who needs her. Savage enemies seething with dark magic are hunting her. A daring, determined revolutionary thinks she could be his people’s savior. And he looks at her in a way that no man has ever looked at her before. Soon it is not just her life, but her very heart that is at stake.

Elisa could be everything to those who need her most. If the prophecy is fulfilled. If she finds the power deep within herself. If she doesn’t die young.

Most of the chosen do.

Stand alone or series: Book 1 in a planned trilogy

How did I get this book: ARC from the Publisher at BEA

Why did I read this book: I am going to be completely shallow and transparent and admit that I decided to read the book almost solely based on the Tamora Pierce blurb. I love Tamora Pierce, people. If she blurbs a new YA fantasy novel that features a strong heroine on a hero’s journey, you bet your ass I’ll read it. I will admit that the ARC cover looked pretty bad in my opinion – but more on cover talk (and misrepresentation – yes, whitewashing and skinny-cizing – later).


The second daughter of the royal family of Orovalle, Princess Lucero-Elisa de Riqueza is not destined for a life of rule from the throne – that is an honor reserved for her beautiful, cunning older sister, Alodia. But Elisa is far from overlooked, as she has a more unique and frightening destiny. As an infant at her nameday ceremony, Elisa is chosen by God when a blinding light overtakes the church, and a godstone lodges itself in her navel. Every century, a person bearing the godstone is chosen for a life of Service; that is, a life marked by some heroic deed that is meant to serve God’s will. Coddled by her nurses and protected by her gruff father and perfect sister, Elisa’s safe, secure life is ripped away on the eve of her sixteenth birthday, when she’s thrust into a world of intrigue. As part of a political concession, Elisa is given in marriage to King Alejandro de Vega of neighboring kingdom Joya d’Arena. Frightened and alone, Elisa leaves Orovalle for a strange new court in the foreign land. Though her bridegroom is kind and assures Elisa that he wants to befriend her and earn her confidence, the new queen notices that something is amiss. First, their caravan is brutally attacked on the way to the palace, leaving many of their party injured and dead. Then, upon arriving in the royal city of Brisadulce, Alexander takes his new wife to separate chambers through a secret palace entrance and pleads with Elisa to keep their marriage – and her role as the once-in-a-century bearer of the godstone – a secret. With war looming on the horizon between Joya d’Arena and the encroaching Invierne, things are tense at court, and secrets abound. When Elisa is kidnapped by an unlikely captor and whisked across the scorching desert to the east and taken to the hills at the farthest edges of the kingdom, she sees first hand what war means for Joya d’Arena, and the battered Joya d’Arenan people of Basajuan. And, perhaps finally, she understands what it means to be a bearer of the godstone and what she must do to help her newfound people survive.

Blurbed by the likes of Tamora Pierce and Megan Whalen Turner, released to overwhelming praise from the blogosphere and lit critics alike, one could say that The Girl of Fire and Thorns has some big shoes to fill. With that kind of hype, it’s rare for a book to live up to expectations – but I’m very happy to report that with only a few reservations, The Girl of Fire and Thorns does a beautiful job of living up to the challenge of the formidable Hype Machine.

In many ways, The Girl of Fire and Thorns feels like a Young Adult, simpler (and certainly less racy) rendering of a Jacqueline Carey novel. The greatest strengths of Fire and Thorns lie with its effortless plotting, well-conceived world, and sympathetic heroine. For the former, the realms of Orovalle, the stagnant decadence of Brisadulce, and the harsh reality of life on the Hills and fringes of the desert in Basajuan are beautifully rendered. In addition to all three locations being so different in terms of physical geography, topography, and ecosystem, each location has its own separate motives and, to some extent, cultural differences. This is undoubtedly a work of high fantasy, with monarchs scheming in courts with their treacherous backhanded deals and power plays in Brisadulce; and, at the same time, it has plenty of traveling, action, and, of course, war of both the magical and plain bloody variety.

Above all, though, The Girl of Fire and Thorns is a novel about a girl that finds herself responding to the call of destiny. This is Elisa’s tale, and she blossoms from uncertain and self-doubting girl to the leader of a powerful rebellion. Also, notably, Elisa is an overweight heroine – which is almost unheard of in fantasy novels, especially those for Young Adults. When we first meet her, struggling to fit into her wedding dress, she compares herself to a sausage and hopes against all hope that her unseen husband will be ugly, or old, or infirm in some way to protect herself from his inevitable disgust. Even though Elisa is a large girl, though, her weight does not simplify or caricaturize her. We readers feel for Elisa when ladies and maids ridicule her, when a child calls her fat in front of the entire court, when she struggles to keep up with her captors lest she die in the desert, with the disgust that people show when they learn that it is Elisa – soft, overweight Elisa – that is meant to be their hero. She’s not a perfect heroine or a Mary Sue, for all that she’s God’s Chosen, but she finds a way to take on the innumerable challenges thrown in her path with a kind of calm grace and growing sense of confidence and self-respect. Needless to say, I loved every second of her story, as she grows into the powerful Queen she has always had the potential to be. There are plenty of other characters that are fabulous, too – from the indecisive Alexander to the noble Lord Hector, the beautifully treacherous Condessa Ariña and the prickly Cosmé, and, of course, the sweet Humberto and ruthless nursemaid Ximena. I loved them in all of their imperfections and complexity.

On that note, I should also say how much I appreciated the surprisingly brutal developments in terms of the plot. Ms. Carson subscribes to the George R.R. Martin school of fantasy characters – meaning that there are many of them, and no one is safe. I love this kind of sadistic fatalism, especially in a YA novel – but be warned if you like a fantasy where the good guys always emerge victorious, saved at the last minute from harm or death. The Girl of Fire and Thorns may not be for you, if you are that reader.

My only reservation regarding The Girl of Fire and Thorns is with how closely the central theology to the world and novel – integral to the plot and to the shaping of Elisa as a character – sits to Judeo-Christianity. Unlike Jacqueline Carey, for example, who takes familiar foundational religions and histories and crafts entirely new cultures and creation myths from that seed, The Girl of Fire and Thorn is less varied and more of a direct translation of biblical values and teachings. The fictional religion in the novel is monotheistic and follows very similar central tenets to Christianity – often passages that Elisa or others quote even bear very close resemblance to familiar biblical passages (e.g. “Out of the mouth of babes” in scripture versus “From the mouths of innocents flows truth”). As such, the novel could be construed to have something of a double meaning; that is, beyond the story of Elisa and her rise to power and acceptance of self, there’s also this thread that all this is accomplished through the Will of (the Christian) God, and by virtue of her (Christian) faith. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with the latter type of story – it simply isn’t particularly to my tastes. It made me uncomfortable, as with this latter interpretation, Elisa’s hero journey feels eerily like a Christian religious parable. (Of course, there’s the addition of magical birthstones in bellybuttons, trolls-dolls style, which is a clear departure from any sort of religion – so maybe I’m reading too much into the similarities. I don’t think I am, but there you have it.) That said, your mileage may vary – this type of thematic ascription is not something I’m comfortable with, but it certainly doesn’t diminish the book or mean that others wont enjoy it.

Questions of religion aside, overall, I loved this fantastic debut novel. The Girl of Fire and Thorns does, in fact, live up to its preceding hype. While this is the first book in a planned trilogy, it also can be read as a self contained book, and breaks in a sane place (i.e. no terrible, tearing-out-your-hair cliffhanger ending here). I cannot wait for the next book in this promising new trilogy.

Notable Quotes/Parts: Using Harper Teen’s Browse Inside widget below (or online HERE), you can read the first 85 pages of the book:

Additional Thoughts: On the covers, because this bears some mention and discussion: Elisa is not a thin girl. In fact, she is quite overweight, describing herself as such throughout the book. Even when she (involuntarily) loses weight during her abduction and sojourn in the desert, Elisa is never ever portrayed as a dainty girl. Furthermore, she’s dark skinned. So this ARC cover:

Yeah…FAIL. The good news is, the publisher caught it and changed the cover to its current final state (which features a face in the shimmering of a godstone), and the UK cover gets skin tone down perfectly. As we’ve discussed many a time here in Smugglerville, we know that book covers are often misrepresentative of their content – sometimes going as far as whitewashing a character. Something we haven’t talked much about, however, is this concept of slenderizing a plus-sized character for a cover. We’ve seen it before in books like Everything Beautiful. Have you noticed any of this in your reading?

Rating: 8 – Excellent

Reading Next: Daughter of Smoke and Bone by Laini Taylor


Buy the Book:

Ebook available for kindle US, nook, kobo, & apple


  • Kelly L.
    September 21, 2011 at 7:38 am

    I was actually just talking about slenderizing re: Nine Rules to Break when Romancing a Rake. Here is the cover:


    This heroine is supposed to be plump. I look at that cover and see “very slender, but busty.”

  • KMont
    September 21, 2011 at 8:50 am

    *I should also say how much I appreciated the surprisingly brutal developments in terms of the plot. Ms. Carson subscribes to the George R.R. Martin school of fantasy characters – meaning that there are many of them, and no one is safe.*

    I agree that this can be a very fun aspect of some fantasy novels, if done well. Martin definitely does it well!

    I’m not sure I could get past the direct religious similarities, though, if they come off as an attempt to preach to the reader. But yes, the only way for me to tell of course is to read the book. Then again, given the misgivings I felt upon reading that issue, not sure I want to invest the time or not. Guess time will tell.

    However, the heroine’s body issues do seem to give it a unique spin. How often do we hear about an overweight hero?

  • The Girl of Fire and Thornes by Rae Carson (9/20/2011) « DogEar
    September 21, 2011 at 11:27 am

    […] other reviews: A Chair, A Fireplace and a Tea Cozy The Allure of Books Book Smugglers Good Books and Good Wine Melanie’s Musings Miss […]

  • Lori Strongin
    September 21, 2011 at 12:59 pm

    Despite your awesome review, I’m still on the fence about this one. I’m kinda burned out on “girl of prophecy” novels because they all start with the MC wary of/refusing her destiny. Just once, I’d love to see a MC embrace the destiny angle and make it her own, rather than having a personality crafted solely by the prophecy hanging over her.


  • Elizabeth
    September 21, 2011 at 1:19 pm

    Stacked had a fun blog post in 2009 about cover images that deliberately avoid showing overweight characters. I feel like there are a few middle-grade examples, too…darn, Betsy Bird would have them at her fingertips.

  • Kristen
    September 21, 2011 at 4:11 pm

    This sounds great, and it is going straight to the wish list! Especially since so many awesome books I’ve read this year have been recommended by you (The Native Star, Eon/Eona, The Demon King, Cold Magic, The Cloud Roads…).

  • MarieC
    September 21, 2011 at 5:37 pm

    Great review. Regarding covers…well, this happens all the time with the romance genre…

  • Alex
    September 21, 2011 at 6:40 pm

    I was expecting the religious themes to bother me as well, but I thought that Carson did a really good job with them. All too often, I find that in the books that I read, people with faith are either depicted as perfect once they have overcome their doubts (read too many bad Christian novels as a teen…) or they’re depicted as fundamentalist hypocrites. So I found Elisa’s belief quite refreshing – it wasn’t the be-all and end-all of her character, but it added some really interesting depth.

    And yes, I also appreciated Carson’s willingness to kill of characters. *Cue evil laugh*

  • Capillya
    September 21, 2011 at 9:21 pm

    I’m so glad that this novel lived up to the Hype Machine for you! Great review, I’m looking forward to reading it. =)

  • Chachic
    September 21, 2011 at 9:22 pm

    She compares herself to a sausage? I do that too! Although I use the Filipino version, longganisa. I describe myself as longganisa when I can’t fit into my old clothes. I was already curious about this book because of the MWT blurb but it’s good to know that you enjoyed reading it, Thea.

  • helen
    September 22, 2011 at 7:40 pm

    I should have paid attention to that darn warning. I LOVED the first 7/8ths of the book but that last 1/8 killed if for me darn it!

  • Kailana
    September 23, 2011 at 7:54 am

    I have been seeing reviews of this around and I am really interested. I am going to have to get a copy. Thanks for another tempting review!

  • Thea
    September 23, 2011 at 7:58 am

    Thanks for the comments, everyone!

    Kelly L – 😯 Holy crap. THAT is meant to be “plump”? I’d hate to see what skinny looks like.

    KMont – Oh, I wouldn’t worry about preachiness! Girl of Fire and Thorns doesn’t try to push an agenda on anyone – it’s just that the rampant, direct similarities to an already existing religion made me uncomfortable. Just personal preference, I suppose! If you do give this one a go, I’d be really interested to see what you think! And yes, completely agree with you regarding the awesomeness of a plus-size heroine, especially in a fantasy/adventure novel. It brings a whole new perspective to the table.

    Lori – A very fair point! I’m a sucker for the trope (when done well), although it is much more refreshing to read a book about a non-prophesied hero. On that note, have you read Kate Elliott’s Cold Magic? It’s a very interesting take on prophesies and pre-arranged deals/destiny, with an unsuspecting heroine that takes what unfolds in stride and makes her own way. It’s pretty badass. There’s also Brandon Sanderson’s Mistborn trilogy, which plays with the idea of a Hero of Ages that is meant to save the world…and fails. Really great books!

    Elizabeth – Holy moly. THANK YOU for the link! It’s really…well, appalling to see how many covers slenderize characters or avoid them altogether.

    Kristen – I actually was thinking of you when I finished this book! I have a feeling you are gonna love this one a lot 🙂

    MarieC – Does it? I had no clue! Of the romance novels I’ve read, most heroines have been of the usual “dainty” proportions – I’d be really interested to see more examples if you have any?

    Alex – Very true! The way religion is handled in the book is, I think, well done and not heavy handed or preachy at all. It’s just the core concept that I had trouble with (but again, that’s just me!). I cannot wait for the next book – although I am scared for some of my favorite characters. Those deaths completely took me by surprise!

    Capillya – Thanks! I hope you enjoy it as much as I did 🙂

    Chachic – Yes she certainly does! When she tries to fit into her hastily constructed wedding dress, she describes herself as a sausage in a white casing. I think you’ll like this book a lot – can’t wait to see what you think!

    Helen – OMG, right? That death broke my heart. Guh. But it was also awesomely merciless and gives the novel some real teeth. Can’t wait for book 2!

  • Overweight and Invisible « A Fuse #8 Production
    September 29, 2011 at 9:01 pm

    […] they recently reviewed a book called The Girl of Fire and Thorns by Rae Carson and they got to talking about plus sized […]

  • Smugglivus 2011 Guest Author: Rae Carson | The Book Smugglers
    December 15, 2011 at 10:01 am

    […] Work: The excellent Girl of Fire and Thorns which Thea loved and reviewed HERE. The book has recently been announced as one of five William C. Morris YA Debut Award finalists […]

  • Review: The Girl of Fire and Thorns by Rae Carson « Waking Brain Cells
    December 29, 2011 at 1:16 pm

    […] The Book Smugglers […]

  • Rae Carson’s The Girl of Fire and Thorns | Josephine's Readers Advisory
    March 1, 2012 at 11:12 am

    […] reviews: The Book Smuggler School Library Journal Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

  • Rae Carson’s The Girl of Fire and Thorns | Josephine's Readers Advisory
    September 9, 2012 at 3:09 pm

    […] reviews: The Book Smuggler School Library Journal Share this:FacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was […]

  • Recommended Reading: The Girl of Fire and Thorns Trilogy | The Sketchy Feminist
    August 30, 2013 at 1:45 pm

    […] a review of the first book which covers the covers over at The Book Smugglers. The Forever Young Adult review (where I first learned about the book), […]

  • Review: The Girl of Fire and Thorns by Rae Carson - Ticket to AnywhereTicket to Anywhere
    April 27, 2016 at 8:27 am

    […] Book Smugglers – [Elisa]’s not a perfect heroine or a Mary Sue, for all that she’s God’s Chosen, but she finds a way to take on the innumerable challenges thrown in her path with a kind of calm grace and growing sense of confidence and self-respect. […]

  • Emma’s YA Recommendations – The Shelf Life
    March 4, 2017 at 8:46 pm

    […] The Girl of Fire and Thorns, by Rae Carson, ISBN# 8790062026507, $9.99, from Greenwillow. […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.