8 Rated Books Book Reviews

Book Review: A Gathering of Gargoyles by Meredith Ann Pierce

Title: A Gathering of Gargoyles

Author: Meredith Ann Pierce

Genre: Fantasy, Science Fiction, Young Adult

Publisher: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
Publication Date: September 1998
Paperback: 352 pages

Aeriel’s love has broken the curse on the darkangel Irrylath, making him human again and freeing him from the control of his mother, the dreaded White Witch. But the Witch is far from defeated. Her wicked plans require all seven of her vampyre sons, and she will not give one up so easily. There is but a single hope for the Witch’s defeat–solving an ancient, mysterious riddle.

So Aeriel sets off to solve the riddle, sailing across a sea of dust and straight into the worst of the Witch’s terrors. But if Aeriel is to save Irrylath and her world, she will have to overcome his bloodthirsty darkangel brothers–and ultimately confront his terrifying mother face-to-face.

Stand alone or series: Book 2 of the Darkangel Trilogy

How did I get this book/Why did I read this book: Megan no h, one of the lovely gals behind Forever Young Adult, was kind enough to send me a copy of this book (AND a copy of the final book in the trilogy) when she saw how much I loved The Darkangel. I have been shamefully lazy in actually getting around to reading and reviewing the book – but here it is, at long last!

**WARNING: This review contains unavoidable spoilers for The Darkangel, book 1 in the series. If you have not read The Darkangel and would like to remain unspoiled, LOOK AWAY! You have been warned.**


After cutting out her own heart and giving it to the darkangel Irrylath, Aeriel has not only found a way to save her world from the clutches of the White Witch and her seven icari, but she has also found a way to save Irrylath’s soul. After breaking the curse on her new bridegroom, Aeriel and Irrylath make their way to Isternes, the childhood home of Irrylath, before he was treacherously traded away to the White Witch by his nursemaid Dirna for life and power. Here, Irrylath finds his true mother, his brothers, and his birthright as the eldest son and heir to the land – but though he and Aeriel are welcomed with open arms by his Esternese kin, their struggles remain.

Irrylath remains plagued by terrible dreams and withdraws from Aeriel’s touch and compassion – and Aeriel learns that her husband, in name if not in truth, still is snared by the hook of the White Witch. If she is to save him – and to truly save her world from the Witch, who even now searches for a new babe to make into a darkangel – Aeriel must embark on a dangerous quest, and solve an ancient, hidden riddle.

A Gathering of Gargoyles continues the story of a brave young woman named Aeriel, who has inexplicably become the one person that can stand against an evil that threatens to consumer her world. And, dear readers, I loved this book so very much. I must start this review properly by thanking the lovely Megan no h for her emphatic recommendation, because A Gathering of Gargoyles is truly and utterly awesome. It is in fact a better novel than The Darkangel; The Empire Strikes Back to the first novel’s Star Wars. I know that science fiction analogy may seem at first blush NOT to make sense with this trilogy, but in actuality it has far more resonance than one might suspect – because A Gathering of Gargoyles makes it abundantly clear that this series is actually one rooted in science fiction. Aeriel’s world, as it becomes known in A Gathering of Gargoyles, is actually our moon; a “daymonth” to Aeriel and her fellow creatures, is the equivalent to a lunar day, with the constant companion of the Earth, or “Oceanus” to Aeriel, shining its pale blue light upon the moon’s surface. Unlike our current moon, though, Aeriel’s world is a place of impossible, fantastical life – in which there are seas of dust hiding moonwhales and serpents, with deserts and forests, gargoyles and lons.

This is the most impressive thing about this trilogy, and A Gathering of Gargoyles in particular – the incredible scope of imagination. To be sure, this is a fantasy novel with magical creatures and gifts, but the story never once feels tired or familiar because of the magic of Ms. Pierce’s prose and the wildly imaginative setting. Reading A Gathering of Gargoyles is almost like being in a dream – things are strange and ever-shifting, but you never really feel confused or lost, because it is your dream, and impossible things are accepted as a matter of course.

From a pure story perspective, the actual plot of the novel is fairly simple – Aeriel leaves Isternes to find the lost lons, so that Irrylath’s brothers can ride them into battle against the White Witch – and her journey takes her to the edges of the world. In truth, the story is about Aeriel as she discovers who she is, what she is truly capable of, and how far she will go to stop the Witch and win Irrylath’s heart. The riddle – actually more of a prophecy – that sparks her journey lies at the heart of the book, and I love that its meaning changes as Aeriel’s self-awareness grows.

For all that she is risking everything for Irrylath, this is truly Aeriel’s story, and I loved every last second of it. I loved following Aeriel from Isternes, across the Sea-of-Dust, to singing for her sup and on the run from bandits, to the desperate land of Pirs and the terrible truth of its ruler, to eventually back in her own home of Terrain. On each leg of her far journey, Aeriel learns a new truth, gathering Irrylath’s former gargoyle guards along the way. My main complaint for The Darkangel was Aeriel’s lack of oomph, and her utter, unflinching goodness. While she is still unerringly moral and good in A Gathering of Gargoyles, this book shows us glimpses of her vulnerability. She falls for the tricks of a false king and a hag; she shows her frustration when all her work seems to have gone to waste. And, most touchingly, we feel her heart breaking as she realizes the truth of Irrylath and that he does not love her.

This volume ends on a sweet note, with the promise of even more fantastic adventure and peril ahead – the trilogy must close with Aeriel and Irrylath’s confrontation of the White Witch, and I cannot wait to find out how it all ends.

If you haven’t read this gem of a series before, I implore you to find a used copy and start. Absolutely, wholeheartedly recommended, and one of my most cherished finds of the year.

Notable Quotes/Parts: From Chapter 4:

Aeriel’s craft sped over the Sea-of-Dust, riding the swells that rolled like water and glowed by starlight with their own internal fire. Beneath the surface, Aeriel saw the silt-fine particles constantly shifting. Wind stole a few from the crests of the waves, whirling them off in dust devils against the dark, starry sky.

So fine were the grains that Aeriel could scarcely see them, hardly felt them when she breathed, aware at first only of their faint, tangy aroma. Before many hours, though, she found her throat growing dry. Her eyes felt grainy, her fingers paper-leathery.

Tying the sail and tiller into place, she drew out from her provisions a loongrass bulb and bit through the white, parchmentlike skin. The meat inside was stiff, the juice astringent but satisfying. She needed only a few bites before the feeling of dryness eased.

The colors of the Sea were changing now. Close in to shore, the dust had been greyish, almost buff-colored. But as she sailed farther, deeper to sea, the dust grew paler, clear yellow green, and later violet. Sometimes the waves rolled mauve.

Stars turned. Night drifted by. Oceanus peered over the rim of the world, and Aeriel’s heart lifted, soared. The air was showered in its ghost-blue light. Gradually, the planet rose.

Rating: 8 – Excellent

Reading Next: Seraphina by Rachel Hartman

Buy the Book: (click on the links to purchase)

No Ebook Available.


  • Angie
    July 5, 2012 at 9:42 am

    Love the Empire Strikes Back analogy. Was exactly what I thought when I first read A GATHERING OF GARGOYLES. Such a stellar sequel.

  • Thea
    July 5, 2012 at 10:12 am

    Angie, I cannot believe that I had not discovered this series until now! This book was just so…wow. It’s one of the ones I finished and hugged close to my chest before reluctantly putting it on my “to be loved forever” shelf.

    Now I am frantically looking for more books by the author. Have you read her Firebringer books? Those are next on my wishlist!

  • Lexi
    July 5, 2012 at 11:04 am

    It is fun to read the review of these. They were a childhood favorite. I started with her Firebringer trilogy, which I recommend, and bothered the interlibrary loan desk at my little library until I got all of her books.

  • Thea
    July 5, 2012 at 1:00 pm

    Lexi – Awesome! I just purchased the first Firebringer book (they are available as ebooks! Huzzah!). I love that I can completely tell that these are books that I would have fallen in love with as a younger reader, but still manage to stand the test of time so many years later. Thanks for the rec!

  • Andrea K Host
    July 5, 2012 at 7:28 pm

    There’s few books with some a unique voice and powerful world as this. I first encountered “Darkangel” at my local library, and it was one of those incredibly compelling stories which led me to hunt down my own copies of the trilogy.

    I’ll be interested to see how you react to how this series closes. Aeriel is definitely more active and purposeful, but, well, I often tell people to only read the first book in this series.

  • Megan no h
    July 5, 2012 at 8:33 pm

    EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! I have been SO EXCITED for this review! So glad you liked it! GoG was always my favorite of the trilogy, because it was like HOT DAMN, there is WAY MORE going on in this story than I would have ever thought from the first book.

    I read the Firebringer trilogy way back when (I had to ILL that shiz, because that was pre-used book sites), but I can’t remember it all that well. I remember not liking it as much as the Darkangel books, but then…I was looking for something too similar. I know some people even prefer the Firebringer books. Also, unicorns!

  • Thea
    July 6, 2012 at 1:26 pm

    Andrea – I’m a little nervous now to read the final book in the trilogy, but I have to know how it all ends. Personally, I liked this book a lot more than the first one, though The Darkangel will always hold a special place in my heart now. Thanks for the comment (and for the heads up for book 3).

    Megan – AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!! FINALLY! Thank you so so SO much again for the copy of this book. You were absolutely 100% right – I loved this book so much.

    And thanks for the Firebringer note!! I AM ON IT. Unicorns FTW!

  • Kate
    July 8, 2012 at 3:19 pm

    Oh, man, it’s been so long since I read that trilogy– but I really loved them when I read them! Need to get hold of reading copies so I can read them again– thanks for the reminder! 😀

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.