Smugglivus Smugglivus Guest Blogger

Smugglivus 2015 Guest Blogger: Renay of Lady Business with an October Daye Primer

Welcome to Smugglivus 2015! Throughout this month, we will have daily guests – authors and bloggers alike – looking back at their favorite reads of 2015, looking forward to events and upcoming books in 2016, and more.

Who: Renay, one of the co-editors of the excellent blog Lady Business, a Strange Horizons columnist, co-editor of Speculative Fiction 2014, and co-host (with Ana) of Fangirl Happy Hour.

Lady Business

As is now traditional, Renay is again our last Smugglivus Guest Blogger of the year!

In 2014, I co-reviewed Rosemary and Rue by Seanan McGuire with my co-editor, Jodie (beware spoilers, we Go Deep in co-reviews). Looking back on that discussion, I had no clue what I was getting into, what Seanan McGuire was going to make me want as a reader, and absolutely no idea that less than a year later I was going to do a deep dive into the October Daye series.

It started when my library only had four books out of the nine-book series. Once I started requesting them and my library kept ordering and handing them over to me, I couldn’t stop. On one hand, my library is awesome. On the other hand, now I’m going to be the person waiting for my personal copy on release day and shoving the whole book into my face within the first 24 hours. It’s that kind of series for me now. I am one of the Converted.


Urban Fantasy isn’t a genre I read very often and stories about faeries and faerie court politics even less so. But something about the October Daye series allowed me to get beyond the premise and the world building and to the core of the work, which is very character-focused and places emphasis on interpersonal relationships in a way that really appeals to me. The political shenanigans and mysteries can be a good time, watching Toby brute force her way through them even more so, but what kept me coming back to the series were Toby’s relationships.

The series begins with Toby alone, isolated, and without a core community or family. Nine books in, this has drastically changed, and the way it does so is some of the best character development and interpersonal drama I’ve ever had the pleasure to read. People (and faeries) are complicated and contradictory and impatient and sometimes cruel. But people (and faeries) also have infinite capacity for love and compassion and understanding. Some of the most gut-wrenching emotional moments in the series aren’t big reveals or story climaxes, but instead quiet moments between individual characters when feelings and the future of the relationship is on the line. And, because this series is the series it is, it’s full of the flaws of humanity, it doesn’t always go the way we as readers want it to go. It feels very nuanced and cratered. It feels true to a life lived — happiness found, lost, but eventually rediscovered — as we watch Toby navigate the world she inhabits as a half-human, half-faerie changeling.


It’s hard to talk about a series that’s already very long and convince people to read it without spoiling everything after the second and third books. Although Rosemary and Rue is a good first novel and a great introduction to the world, the way the series grows and changes make that first book a little unrecognizable looking back. This series is change on both a personal and grand scale: the characters live and grow and aren’t the same people in one book that they are in the next and it all feels natural. The world changes, too. This series captures life and how messy and inconvenient and wonderful it can be. It just adds a little magic and faerie court politics to make it interesting.

The series also does something I have missed seeing in a lot of media I read and watch. The men are emotionally expressive with the women in their lives as well as other men, which feels so real and vivid to me because I grew up in groups where men were casually intimate with the people around them who they were close to. This is often missing from a lot of original media that I experience, whether due to the kind of story it is or Obligatory Heteronormativity with a side of Toxic Masculinity. But there are so many moments in the series that I know in other narratives we simply wouldn’t see between men and boys (both with each other and women). There’s also the absence of the looming specter of sexual violence. I can’t argue that this series isn’t violent — if they did a TV series the main expense would be vats of fake blood — but it’s not violent in a very particular way. To someone who reads in genres that put women in sexual peril as window dressing, you get fantastic at sussing out the clues and hints that it’s coming. But it never happens here and it makes the reading experience flat out amazing.


And I could go on forever and ever about the friendships between Toby and the women she surrounds herself with, because I find these relationships so wonderful to read about and reflective of the relationships I have with the women around me, too. I never expected to go into an urban fantasy series about faeries and come out so invested in reading about solid, supportive friendships. Because, honestly, there’s not much drama to be had there. But for me that’s sort of the point: Toby’s relationships, as they develop, anchor and enrich her life in ways that don’t have to be dramatic to be rewarding and entertaining. It’s wonderful to watch friendship be allowed to simply exist.

I spent a good chunk of my 2015 reading and loving the October Daye series. If you haven’t yet taken the plunge and are looking for a good series to sink your teeth into, this one is a great choice. There’s still several books to come so you’ll get to join the ride to the very end with the rest of us, too.


  • de Pizan
    January 6, 2016 at 1:04 am

    I love this series. And most of what McGuire has written. I also love the lack of alpha males–if one shows up it’s usually a bad guy, and love the lack of a lot of the other more troubling tropes of urban fantasy (it’s a genre I love, but it’s got a lot of issues). McGuire has said in the past that she will never feature rape/sexual assault as a storyline for her heroines.

  • Anonymous
    January 6, 2016 at 3:43 am

    I LOVE THIS SERIES, and first read about it right here years ago! 🙂

  • Jennifer | Book Den
    January 6, 2016 at 10:39 am

    OK, now I feel like I have to read this series. THE WHOLE SERIES. Thanks, Renay. 😉

  • Renay
    January 6, 2016 at 11:23 am

    HA HA, JENNIFER, I got you. 😉

  • MaxL
    January 6, 2016 at 4:03 pm

    Do we have a rough idea when it’ll be done? I read the first ages ago and liked it, but I’m…hesitant to jump on board a series that’s 9 books long with no end in sight.

  • tanita
    January 6, 2016 at 4:22 pm

    I stumbled onto this series and have made a nuisance of myself at the library in ensuing years. Finally decided it’s faster to buy my own copy then donate it. I was inspired to read all of S. McGuire’s work because of the first book in this series.

  • de Pizan
    January 6, 2016 at 4:28 pm

    MaxL, McGuire currently has a contract with DAW for 13 books in the series, with the 13th projected out in 2019. She hasn’t said if she plans to keep going after that, other than that the number in the series depends on how pacing goes and her enjoyment of writing it.

  • Mervi
    January 7, 2016 at 2:12 pm

    Great review! I’m also a fan of this series. It just gets better with every book.

  • 2015 Reading Year in Review: Urban Fantasy | From My Wandering Mind
    January 8, 2016 at 6:40 pm

    […] If not, it can only be because I don’t talk to you enough because YOU NEED TO READ IT. Look: Book Smugglers even just posted an October Daye primer. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, every book in this series seems better than […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.