6 Rated Books Book Reviews Joint Review Smugglivus

Joint Review: Cinder by Marissa Meyer

Title: Cinder

Author: Marissa Meyer

Genre: Science Fiction, Young Adult

Publisher: Feiwel & Friends
Publication date: January 3rd 2012
Hardcover: 387 pages

Humans and androids crowd the raucous streets of New Beijing. A deadly plague ravages the population. From space, a ruthless lunar people watch, waiting to make their move. No one knows that Earth’s fate hinges on one girl. . . .

Cinder, a gifted mechanic, is a cyborg. She’s a second-class citizen with a mysterious past, reviled by her stepmother and blamed for her stepsister’s illness. But when her life becomes intertwined with the handsome Prince Kai’s, she suddenly finds herself at the center of an intergalactic struggle, and a forbidden attraction. Caught between duty and freedom, loyalty and betrayal, she must uncover secrets about her past in order to protect her world’s future.

In this thrilling debut young adult novel, the first of a quartet, Marissa Meyer introduces readers to an unforgettable heroine and a masterfully crafted new world that’s enthralling.

Stand alone or series: First in the Lunar Chronicles series

How did we get this book: Review copies via NetGalley

Why did we read this book: Cinder is a futuristic retelling of Cinderella in which she is a freaking Cyborg! How could we not want to read this?


First Impressions:

Ana: I had high expectations for Cinder based on the positive advance reviews I’ve seen and on how much I wanted to read a futuristic retelling of Cinderella in which the main character is a Cyborg – and in the words of Doctor Who: Cyborgs are cool. And “cool” is a perfectly fine word for this book – not only it meshes really well the fairytale elements with the futuristic setting but it also introduces a likable, capable female protagonist that I could totally root for.

Thea: I, too, had high expectations for Cinder because the concept is so risque and brilliant. Cybernetic Cinderella in a future dystopian iteration of a China on the precipice of war with an evil Lunar Empire? YES. And you know what? Cinder absolutely delivers on the entertainment and action scale and I thoroughly enjoyed the story…with a few reservations.

On the Plot:

Ana: It is the future, years after World War IV and the planet is plagued by a deadly disease called letumosis. In New Beijing, teenage Cinder is a Cyborg – part human, part robot – whose talent for mechanics is exploited by her selfish Stepmother, who is her official Guardian, after the death of her adoptive father. As a Cyborg, Cinder is universally despised and the thing she fears the most is the Draft: in which Cyborgs are drafted by the government to become test subjects to find the cure for the plague and no Cyborg has ever survived it. Unfortunately for Cinder, her beloved stepsister Peony catches the disease the same day that her services as a mechanic are required by cute Prince Kai. Both occurrences set in motion a chain of events in which she discovers the truth about her own blood and finds herself at the center of political intrigues with the horrible, warmongers Lunar people.

Story-wise, Cinder has different yet interconnected threads. On one hand, there is Cinder and her family life, her difficulties at being unloved and exploited by her stepfamily which in this novel are further complicated by the fact that she is a Cyborg in a world that doesn’t exactly welcome them as equal beings to humans. On the other hand, there is the world in the future and the plague, the stress of the politics between the Earth and the Moon and its Lunar people and their Queen. All of this combines in a way to build Cinder’s internal and external conflict and I thought all was really well done especially with regards to the world-building and the fairytale crossover. Although the Cinderella elements are almost secondary to the story, I thought they were expertly handled by the author and it was fun how certain aspects of the tale were incorporated differently here (like the shoe, the carriage, etc). It also has to be said that there is of course, a certain level of predictability stemming from the connection with Cinderella as well as fairly obvious plot twist about Cinder’s true identity. In fact, this was so obvious that I suggest this was done on purpose. To me, it made it all the more fun to follow Cinder through the discoveries she was making.

That said, whilst I thought these elements to be well done, and the world-building to be fairly developed, the same can’t be said about the particular setting of this story. The story is set in a place called New Beijing and for all intents and purposes everything sounds Chinese and it seems that everything should be Chinese but there is never a clear description of its people (I still don’t know how Prince Kai LOOKS LIKE, for example. I know he is supposed to be cute and hot but in what way I don’t know), is places, its culture. It is a potentially cool, different setting that is grossly under-developed to the point where I wondered what was the point? It was not a deal-breaker because I truly enjoyed everything else but it was quite frustrating.

It also needs to be said that Cinder is the first in a new series so although this first book follows the story of Cinderella, I believe this fairytale element is basically over now. It will be interesting to see how the story develops.

Thea: I agree with much of what Ana says – the parts of the book I loved the most were the action elements of the plot. While the “Cinderella” retelling is pretty ancillary to the plot, I still loved the clever way Ms. Meyer incorporates key elements of the fairytale with a cyborg twist. (Cinder’s foot, for example, is completely robotic, and it falls off at a key scene. You get the picture.) I also loved the creation of an evil lunar empire, watching the Earth from not so far away and scheming towards solar system domination. These Lunars have mind-manipulative abilities that poor Earthlings are unable to resist, and the Lunar Queen is the most skilled enchantress (well, technically bioelectrical manipulation master) of the bunch. There’s something deliciously Star Wars-esque about the Lunars and their Queen (who, underneath her immaculate glamour I’m sure looks JUST like Chancellor Palpatine-cum-Super Wrinkly Evil Emperor).

While there is a layer of tensions and discrimination between Earthers and Lunars, there’s also a deeper divide between human and cyborg – for all that Cinder is 2/3 flesh and blood, her cybernetic parts mean that she is not allowed to own anything and is the property of her stepmother. It’s a great opportunity for a deeper examination of slavery, ownership, and humanity, and though Marissa Meyer only superficially deals with these hefty thematic issues in Cinder (primarily through the eyes of Cinder, but also with regards to Cinder’s dear friend and loyal family droid Iko), I have high hopes that as Cinder’s strength and awareness grows, these themes will be dealt with more at length in future books.1

While I did love these aspects of the book, I do have some niggling reservations that prevented me from enjoying it more. First, there’s the predictability of the plot – you know the “twist” from very early on in the story, and as the reveal is made basically on the last page of the novel, this indicates it is supposed to be a huge revelation and/or cliffhanger. Yeah, not so much. There are also the larger problems of plausibility and worldbuilding. Unlike Ana, I am not quite persuaded by the haphazard world created by Ms. Meyer in Cinder. This is supposed to be a future iteration of a war and plague devastated world, set in “New Beijing”. Yet, besides the name New Beijing and some half-hearted attempts and Chinese names2, there is nothing tying this story to Beijing or China in the slightest. There are no cultural references, no exploration of custom, and there’s an odd absence of detail when it comes to setting and description. For all we know, this story could have been set in New Geneva and it would have worked exactly the same – and this, to me, is a really big problem.3 Beyond the lack of any cultural makeup to the novel, my other sizable issue with regards to the world is the plausibility chasm. Are we meant to believe that in a New Beijing overrun with a deadly, incurable plague, the super swoony HEIR PRINCE walks about market stalls willy-nilly, looking for teenage mechanics to repair his SUPER SECRET android? Wouldn’t he, I don’t know, SUMMON the best mechanic in all the land to the palace, make sure they undergo rigorous plague testing, and then keep them under lock and key until the job is done? Furthermore, the instant attraction that blooms between Kai and Cinder strikes me as wholly artificial and a plot device to move the story along/keep it in tune with the guise of the fairytale…and I just can’t quite buy it. But more on that in a bit.

On the Characters:

Ana: I liked most characters, both the secondary ones and the protagonist Cinder – I thought she was easily relatable, how she is capable, and a mechanic with serious skills and how ultimately, she acted as her own fairy godmother. I also appreciated the choices that were made toward the end of the story not only by Cinder but also by Prince Kai.

Speaking of which, there are a few chapters from Prince Kai’s point of view as well but I never really got why this was needed at all because even with chapters from his point of view, Kai remains a mystery to me. The biggest problem I had with the book though, is how I wasn’t entirely sold on the budding romance between Kai and Cinder as Kai’s attraction to Cinder seemed to have been developed out of nowhere and was puzzling to say the least. In all fairness, this was not the central focus of the story.

A final word about the main villain, the Lunar Queen Levana: she was cool. Cold, evil, and ruthless. She is someone to be REALLY feared bringing high levels of real danger to this story.

Thea: The saving grace for the book, to me, is Cinder’s strong characterization. She’s a tough heroine that is capable of love and sorrow (even if her tear ducts have been removed and she can’t cry), and she’s smart and resourceful enough to know that she can only rely on herself to get out of scrapes. There’s no fairy godmother here – unless you count a certain doctor friend – and for the most part, Cinder makes the tough decisions all on her own. THAT is awesome. Also, can I just say that I *love* the vision of a bedraggled, grease-smudged Cinderella, crashing her vintage gasoline car into a tree to make her way to the Ball – not to dance with the Prince, but to save the day?

I have one thing that I have to say about Cinder, though, just to get it off my chest. In a world that is supposedly a future China, in which all of the characters (or at least a good deal of them) are presumably Chinese; in a book that is billed as a future dystopian SF Chinese Cinderella retelling, why is it that our beautiful Cinderella heroine is European/Lunar and Caucasian?4 Ultimately, ethnicity doesn’t change the story or detract from the awesomeness of Cinder’s character, but it bothers me because this is a lost opportunity for a PoC heroine.

I also have to agree with Ana in that I didn’t buy the romance between Kai and Cinder. I don’t really think there’s much to go on with Kai’s character. For all that he seems like a nice guy and hits all the right prince charming notes, there’s nothing distinct, memorable or anything to connect with when it comes to our prince. As far as the other characters are concerned, I share Ana’s appreciation of the Lunar Queen Levana – she’s a pretty badass villainess. The other standout character, to me, is Cinder’s stepmother Adri (though again, weird name choice) – I appreciate that Ms. Meyer shows a depth to Adri and her attachment to Cinder’s adoptive father, which lends a humanity to what could have been a one note villain.

Final Thoughts, Observations & Rating:

Ana: Despite the criticisms I had, I devoured the book in basically one sitting and thoroughly enjoyed it. Will most definitely be back for the sequel.

Thea: Yup, what Ana said. There are some issues with the story that I cannot overlook, but I enjoyed Cinder, and I’ll be back for book 2.

Notable Quotes/Parts: From Chapter 1:

The screw through cinder’s ankle had rusted, the engraved cross marks worn to a mangled circle. Her knuckles ached from forcing the screwdriver into the joint as she struggled to loosen the screw one gritting twist after another. By the time it was extracted far enough for her to wrench free with her prosthetic steel hand, the hairline threads had been stripped clean.

Tossing the screwdriver onto the table, Cinder gripped her heel and yanked the foot from its socket. A spark singed her fingertips and she jerked away, leaving the foot to dangle from a tangle of red and yellow wires.

She slumped back with a relieved groan. A sense of release hovered at the end of those wires— freedom. Having loathed the too-small foot for four years, she swore to never put the piece of junk back on again. She just hoped Iko would be back soon with its replacement.

Cinder was the only full-service mechanic at New Beijing’s weekly market. Without a sign, her booth hinted at her trade only by the shelves of stock android parts that crowded the walls. It was squeezed into a shady cove between a used netscreen dealer and a silk merchant, both of whom frequently complained about the tangy smell of metal and grease that came from Cinder’s booth, even though it was usually disguised by the aroma of honey buns from the bakery across the square. Cinder knew they really just didn’t like being next to her.

A stained tablecloth divided Cinder from browsers as they shuffled past. The square was filled with shoppers and hawkers, children and noise. The bellows of men as they bargained with robotic shop keepers, trying to talk the computers down from their desired profit t margins. The hum of ID scanners and monotone voice receipts as money changed accounts. The netscreens that covered every building and filled the air with the chatter of advertisements, news reports, gossip.

You can read the full excerpt HERE.

Notable Quotes/Parts: There’s a free short story prequel to Cinder available on Tor.com – it’s non-spoilery, so definitely worth checking out!

There’s also the official facebook page, and the official trailer (we’re sorry, but it is terrible and cheesy as hell).

Also, apparently the Lunar Chronicles are not solely focused on Cinder and her story (actually, we don’t know if they are focused on Cinder at all in the subsequent books). Due out in 2013, 2014, and 2015, respectively, are the subsequent novels in the Lunar Chronicles, which also present futuristic sci-fi twists on fairytales: Scarlet is inspired by Little Red Riding Hood, Cress is a take on Rapunzel, and Winter offers a spin on Snow White and the Seven Dwarves. This is awesome and all well and good, but we can’t help but be a little concerned that we won’t get more of Cinder’s clearly unfinished story.


Ana: 6 – Good, recommended with reservations

Thea: 6 – Good, but with some sizable reservations

Reading Next: The Serpent Sea by Martha Wells

Buy the Book:

Ebook available for kindle US, kindle UK, nook, kobo, google and sony

  1. Although…Ana and I have just learned that Cinder is the first in a quartet that each explore different fairy tale retellings. Does this mean we won’t get more of Cinder’s story? Or will they all be interwoven? If this is the last we see of Cinder, then I’m disappointed.
  2. Many of the names are actually more Japanese sounding (e.g. Iko and Kaito), while many of them are just strange names that fit a typical Western European-esque mold (e.g. Peony, Pearl).
  3. The obvious and immediate counterpoint is Paolo Bacigalupi’s The Windup Girl, featuring a sythentic heroine (not too unlike Cinder) and set in a future dystopian Thailand that is impeccably described and rich in culture, detail, and utterly believable because of it.
  4. If we are meant to take the book trailer seriously, then Cinder IS Caucasian, as the publisher clearly states: “Live-action trailers for all four installments of the Lunar Chronicles were shot in Manhattan last week in a single session, to ensure continuity in the depiction of the characters. Meyer provided the publisher with detailed synopses of each of the books and descriptions of their key characters to help casting agents find actors for the shoot who “really fit the billing,” Killick says.”


  • Michelle
    December 30, 2011 at 10:29 am

    I didn’t quite love this one as much as others in the blogosphere did. Like Thea, the insta-love scenario did nothing for me. I felt zero chemistry until the end where there was a dose of conflict brought in. That alone makes me interested to see more of the story in book too. Now, I didn’t realize that the remaining books in the series wouldn’t be focused on Cinder. I certainly hope we see what happens to her given the end of this story. It wasn’t really the happily ever after of the original fairy tale.

  • Etta
    December 30, 2011 at 10:53 am

    I agree with all of your criticisms, but in the end, I really loved this book. It’s one of those cases where I can pinpoint the flaws, but the stuff I loved in it far outweighed the less than perfect stuff. In terms of Cinder being Caucasian, since there was little to no mention of what anyone looked like, and no one ever mentioned Cinder looking different than everyone else around her, I sort of figured the story was set far enough in the future that different ethnicities might have interbred so much that differences in appearance might not be too obvious. After watching the awful book trailer, I realize I’m probably being way too optimistic since Cinder is clearly Caucasian (sigh).

    I’m really disappointed to hear that the subsequent books may not focus on Cinder. There’s still a lot of story to be told here.

  • Angie
    December 30, 2011 at 11:16 am

    Yeah, the end is what concerns me. She has to finish the story . . . doesn’t she?

  • Miss Bookiverse
    December 30, 2011 at 1:27 pm

    I really enjoyed the book. Just wanted to mention that I e-mailed the author when I finished it and asked her about the sequels, she said that Cinder’s story will continue but that we’ll meet new characters as well.

  • Megan no h
    December 30, 2011 at 2:11 pm

    YES. I agree with everything here (both bad and good!) So many problems when I stopped to think about it, but yet, I had fun.

  • Chris
    December 30, 2011 at 3:05 pm

    My issue with this book was that it stayed too close to the Cinderella story. I agree with Thea that the prince should have locked her up. I couldn’t believe that she was off at the junkyard instead of working on her royal commission or fixing the phone for her dying sister. And for how long his father was ill, I was surprised how unprepared the prince was to rule his country. I also kept thinking “New Beijing” was in Vancouver or somewhere where Beijing isn’t. But it was still fun. Hopefully the next one will be better!

  • rhapsodyinbooks
    December 30, 2011 at 5:53 pm

    Oh I’m so dismayed we won’t get more of the Cinder story! It certainly did seem to stop in the middle of things. As far as Kai’s attraction to her, I thought it was because she was the only one in the entire kingdom who wasn’t fawning all over him; the only one who was “real” [sic].

  • Jill of The O.W.L.
    December 31, 2011 at 7:44 am

    I am soooooo glad to hear I’m not the only one who did LOVE this book crazy like. I liked it. I really did. But there was just something missing that made me really love it. And I think it was the predictability. It lacked the amount of tension needed to make me really really love it. I too though will be picking up the next book because I do want to know what happens.

  • Cinder by Marissa Meyer | Janicu's Book Blog
    January 14, 2012 at 10:48 am

    […] with reservations.   Buy: Amazon | Powell’s | The Book Depository   Other reviews: The Book Smugglers – 6 (Good, recommended with reservations) Good Books and Good Wine – loved it Books and […]

  • Book Review: Cinder by Marissa Meyer | The Discriminating Fangirl
    January 23, 2012 at 10:00 am

    […] Elsewhere The Book Smugglers Rhapsody in Books Novel Novice Wondrous Reads Share this: Tagged with: cinder • cyberpunk […]

    March 18, 2012 at 9:51 pm

    […] from The Book Smugglers: “I also have to agree with Ana in that I didn’t buy the romance between Kai and Cinder. I […]

  • Cinder Marissa Meyer Book Review
    May 26, 2012 at 3:21 pm

    […] The Book Rat Paranormal Indulgence The Book Swarm Angieville Beyond Books inkcrush The Book Smugglers […]

  • Hunter
    January 19, 2013 at 1:49 pm

    Marissa Meyer said she thought of Cinder as looking like a Japanese model, so Cinder is probably Asian. The Lunar people are most likely made of many races, as Winter is apparently going to black. Levana’s race is debatable, but she may be partially Asian. Cinder’s mother may have had her with an Asian-Lunar to explain why she looks mostly Asian

  • The Exotic Place as Other (and notes on cinder, by marissa meter) | No Award
    July 31, 2013 at 8:23 pm

    […] Book Smugglers in a review note that the story is set in New Beijing but really fails to capitalise on that and in […]

  • Anonymous
    October 6, 2013 at 4:10 pm


  • RED
    May 19, 2015 at 7:49 pm

    I know this is super late, but I always like it when questions in threads are answered. So word of God is, Cinder is mixed ethnicity, part Asian part Caucasian. http://www.marissameyer.com/blogtype/a-guide-to-lunar-chronicles-character-traits/
    The trailers are horrible not only in cheesiness, but in choice of actors, apparently.

  • Book Review: Cinder – Because Why Not…
    September 28, 2016 at 1:49 pm

    […] (source) […]

  • 2016: Cinder (Marissa Meyer) – Confessions of a Bibliophile
    December 23, 2016 at 8:18 pm

    […] one sitting and thoroughly enjoyed it. Will most definitely be back for the sequel.” — The Book Smugglers (Ana and […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.